Obra Dinn, Roottrees, and Generative AI in game development
Earlier this month, I learned about The Roottrees are Dead, a game that was recently released on Steam. The game was pitched to me as being ‘heavily inspired’ by Lucas Pope’s genius deduction game, Return of the Obra Dinn, one of my favorite all-time gaming experiences, and it immediately shot to the top my backlog of games to play.
The Roottrees are Dead did not disappoint – its ability make you feel like an amateur gumshoe makes it a worthy addition to the genre (btw – any recommendations for similar games are always welcomed), and it more of less took over the entirety of my weekend as I scribbled on series of scrap papers to jot down important tidbits, draw connections, and solve the mystery of the Roottrees.
Like Obra Dinn, it to enlists the player to use a combination of logic, deduction, and careful reading to fill out a blank family tree (vs Obra Dinn’s empty log book) and identify each family member by appearance and occupation (vs Obra Dinn’s appearance and cause of death). Players glean information by typing in keywords into an (imaginary) search engine, no doubt heavily inspired by another wonderful ‘indie’ game, Sam Barlow’s Her Story (I’ve since pitched this game to multiple friends as Obra Dinn meets Her Story, which no doubt led to a couple referral purchases). The game layers in a mid/late-90s AOL / Altavista era motif, and altogether made for a great ~10-15 hour experience.
However, what’s interesting about The Roottrees are Dead is the story of its development, and how it ended up landing on Steam and experiencing its breakout success.
After a bit post-Roottrees come-down internet sleuthing, I learned that the game was initially developed as a browser-based experience released for free on itch.io by a solo programmer developing the game “in his spare time”. The itch.io experience relied heavily on Midjourney to make the game come to life, which led to its free release on itch.io (as opposed to Steam due to its banning of AI generated art on their platform.)
As the itch.io experience picked up internet popularity, the developer (Jeremy Johnston) decided to hand over the keys to the project to another developer (Robin Ward), who took the Roottrees concept and brought it into a new game engine, replaced the AI-generated art with professionally illustrated artwork (created by Henning Ludvigson), and added a variety of quality of life and UI/UX improvements to ‘professionalize’ the game and address common community feedback he received on ‘V1’ of the experience (who also tended to take exception to the AI-generated art.)
The Rootstrees are Dead would not exist in its current form without the benefit of generative AI, which enabled a 1-person programmer to bring his concept to life in a way that could be appreciated (and validated) by an initial audience.
Amidst the partisan debate on the impact of gen AI in games, I think this is an instructive and nuanced early case study in how these tools can help inklings or early ideas quickly reach a playable / consumable prototype stage. The absence of Gen AI tools may have otherwise dissuaded Johnston from putting in the time (and importantly the investment) to create his own twist on / love letter to the Obra Dinn experience.
The story of Chants of Sennar’s development (another highly-recommended deduction genre favorite) is a helpful study in contrast – as developers without a strong track record of success, they were forced into a “brutal” nights and weekends development schedule to realize enough of the game to solicit interest from publishers, which subsequently provided the capital to invest in the game’s development and bring it to market.
Returning to Obra Dinn, the game is an unequivocal innovative masterpiece that stands heads-and-shoulder above its progenitors, created by an otherworldly phenomenon who somehow took on programming, design, art, sound & music for the Obra Dinn project (truly astounding). But The Roottrees are Dead is a fantastic game in itself, and is a project well worthy of its $19.99 price tag to be eagerly enjoyed by rabid Obra Dinn fans like myself while we wait for whatever wacky masterpiece Lucas Pope comes up with next (hopefully on a more readily accessible device this time), which may not have existed without the wonderous yet primitive magic of today’s Gen AI tools.