Liberal Arts, 15 Years Later

Thoughts7 min read

One of my early strains of thought on this blog, dating back to 2009 (!), was musings around the decline of academic interest in the liberal arts in favor of more vocationally-oriented training.

Far and away the most popular degrees on campus are found in the Business School (Finance, Management), as well as other professionally-oriented Majors (Nursing, Education.) This represents a seismic shift in University culture and a concerning Gen-Y trend: America’s best and brightest are straying away from their platonic intellectual pursuits in favor of “marketable” majors with safe career paths waiting for them at the end of the tunnel.

The allure of financial success and/or the desire for wealth cannot be ignored as a significant factor behind this seismic shift. The fault is largely blameless, as modern day media surrounds us with stories of instability, foreclosure, and unemployment amidst one of the largest recessions in American history.

(An aside – I find myself surprised to be fairly unabashed sharing writing dating nearly 15 years old)

At the time, I was in college myself (a tender Freshman/Sophomore!), actively pursuing two degrees – a Finance degree from the college of Business, seduced by the swashbuckling, high wire (and high paying) environments explored in writing by Nassim Taleb or Michael Lewis, and the Liberal Arts via an International Politics degree that enabled coursework across history, philosophy, geography, and political science.

Throughout these dual degrees, I found myself struggling with the cognitive dissonance stemming from my lack of enthusiasm for the rote, formulaic approach offered by my Finance instruction in sleek, technology rich classrooms (how many net present value calculations does it take to understand the time-value of money?) against classes in the creakier, less well-endowed basements of older buildings, where world-class professors offered their views on the great writings, politicians, and movements of the world and its infinite complexity.

To this day, I continue to find myself distinctly split between these two worlds – working at the intersection of the arts and technology (video games) in a business-oriented role – preceded by a similarly business-y role in book publishing company. Close enough to the ‘action’ of wideranging intellectual exploration, but still removed enough to keep my head firmly focused on the profit-and-losses of it all.

Fast-forward 15 (!) years, and it appears that the trend away from the liberal arts and towards more vocationally oriented, high compensated careers has continued to follow the trend line – including a continuation of the business/economics pathways and a further shift towards computer science, which was still in its nascency (for reference, Facebook was a ~1,000 person company and still 3 years away from IPO). A useful second-order impact on the massive demand for Computer Science was covered in the Atlantic (Universities Have a Computer Science Problem) and NYTimes (The Hard Part of Computer Science? Getting Into Class), diving into the contradictions behind students’ increasing interest in computer science (and its associated pathway into high-paying software engineering roles) and the weird, winding path of computer science as a discipline.

An article in the New York Times romanticizing a man with 14 advanced degrees shares the state of affairs:

A 2023 survey of Harvard seniors found that 41 percent — 41 percent! — were entering careers in consulting or finance. The same percentage were graduating to a starting salary of at least $110,000, more than double the national median. Last year, the most popular majors at Stanford were economics and computer science. The ultimate value of college for many is the credential, guaranteeing a starting spot many rungs up the ladder of worldly success: Nothing you learn at an elite university is as important as the line on your C.V. that you’ve paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to type. And if you were feeling cynical, you could argue that the time you spend applying to college will affect the rest of your life more than anything in particular that happens while you’re there.

Similarly, The Economist provided an interesting, nuanced take on the continuing phenomenon as part of its special report on Gen Z:

Many have chosen to study subjects that help them find work. In Britain and America Gen Z-ers are avoiding the humanities, and are going instead for more obviously useful things like economics and engineering. Vocational qualifications are also increasingly popular. Young people then go on to benefit from tight labour markets. Like Beyoncé’s protagonist, they can quit their job and find another one if they want more money.

[…]

What does this wealth mean? It can seem as if millennials grew up thinking a job was a privilege, and acted accordingly. They are deferential to bosses and eager to please. Zoomers, by contrast, have grown up believing that a job is basically a right, meaning they have a different attitude to work. Last year Gen Z-ers boasted about “quiet quitting”, where they put in just enough effort not to be fired. Others talk of “bare minimum Monday”. The “girlboss” archetype, who seeks to wrestle corporate control away from domineering men, appeals to millennial women. Gen Z ones are more likely to discuss the idea of being “snail girls”, who take things slowly and prioritise self-care.

The data support the memes. In 2022 Americans aged between 15 and 24 spent 25% less time on “working and work-related activities” than in 2007. A new paper published by the imf analyses the number of hours that people say they would like to work. Not long ago young people wanted to work a lot more than older people. Now they want to work less. According to analysis by Jean Twenge of San Diego State University, the share of American 12th-graders (aged 17 or 18) who see work as a “central part of life” has dropped sharply.

Another consequence is that Gen Z-ers are less likely to be entrepreneurs. We estimate that just 1.1% of 20-somethings in the eu run a business that employs someone else—and in recent years the share has drifted down. In the late 2000s more than 1% of the world’s billionaires, as measured by Forbes, a magazine, were millennials. Back then pundits obsessed over ultra-young tech founders, such as Mark Zuckerberg (Facebook), Patrick Collison (Stripe) and Evan Spiegel (Snapchat). Today, by contrast, less than 0.5% on the Forbes list are Zoomers. Who can name a famous Gen Z startup founder?

Gen Z-ers are also producing fewer innovations. According to Russell Funk of the University of Minnesota, young people are less likely to file patents than they were in the recent past. Or consider the Billboard Hot 100, measuring America’s most popular songs. In 2008, 42% of hits were sung by millennials; 15 years later only 29% were sung by Gen Z-ers. Taylor Swift, the world’s most popular singer-songwriter, titled her most famous album “1989”, after the year of her birth. The world is still waiting for someone to produce “2004”.

In previous generations, the Philosophy or English degree from a well-credentialed institution of higher learning was deemed an innocent quirk, or potentially even an advantageous signal of intellectual flexibility, curiosity, and worldliness.

It certainly didn’t necessarily disadvantage those coming from elite backgrounds seeking to pursue a job in the consulting, finance, or start-up worlds – in fact, more often than not their hiring managers previously shared these wide-ranging backgrounds (as well as an alma mater, fraternity/sorority, or athletic background).

Of course, part of this was also an indication of a broader financial security that enabled students attending private liberal arts colleges paying full tuition to pursuing their intellectual whims, as I probably was less conscious of back in 2009:

A good friend at a California private institution (majoring in Cognitive Science) recently remarked to the degree to which “he lives in a bubble.” That is to say, his peers are surrounded by tenured professors who place little emphasis on the importance of co-ops, resumes, and internships.

Fast-forward to today, it’s clear that the insulation and illusion of the liberal arts college has faded dramatically in lieu of the desire for immediate stability by way of a tech or consulting job based on a boilerplate background, with subsequent post-screen interviews that can be ‘aced.’

Of course, the recent pullback / belt tightening by the technology sector has largely upended this logic, thereby potentially creating yet another interesting dynamic to come – an expansion of the ‘lay flat’ generation, perhaps?